My Medieval King Reality Check Journey
So I’ve been binge-watching these epic king movies lately – you know the ones with massive crowns, non-stop battles, and kings swinging swords like superheroes. Something felt kinda fake, so I grabbed a giant pile of books from the library and dove in. Here’s what I actually did to figure out the big lies.
First up, the war thing. Movies make it look like kings were always personally leading the charge, hacking down enemies left and right. Okay, I started reading actual battle accounts. Found out pretty fast that kings were more like CEOs hiding in the back. Seriously! They were usually surrounded by a giant human shield of bodyguards. Their actual job? Shouting orders and trying not to die. Getting your king killed in battle? Total disaster for the whole kingdom, way worse than losing some regular knights. This whole “king on the frontline swinging wildly” idea? Pure movie magic. The real goal was not dying, not getting hero shots.
Next shocker: the money situation. Every film shows kings swimming in gold coins like Scrooge McDuck, right? Wrong. I started digging into old financial records (yeah, surprisingly boring stuff for medieval kings). Turns out these guys were constantly broke! Had massive land? Sure, but it wasn’t like instant cash. They needed money fast – for soldiers, castles, fancy feasts to impress other lords. So what did they do? Tax everyone into the ground! Borrow like crazy from annoying moneylenders! Sell off pieces of the royal forest! Then I saw all these lists for royal expenses: feeding hundreds of servants daily, buying thousands of candles for drafty castles, paying the stonemasons to fix the walls… again. Kings weren’t swimming in riches; they were drowning in bills and begging for cash. Being king was basically running a massive, constantly broke corporation.
Finally, the power myth. Movies make the king look like he snaps his fingers and everyone jumps. Did my research and wow, reality was messy. Found tons of accounts of kings arguing with powerful grumpy nobles in big meetings. These nobles were crucial – they controlled the land that gave the king his soldiers. If the king annoyed them too much? Rebellion! Also, the Church? Huge power. Kings needed the pope and bishops on their side. Then there were the ancient rules and traditions… kings couldn’t just invent new laws whenever they felt like it. They had old charters to respect, customs to follow, city leaders to bargain with. Being king was less “supreme dictator” and more “chief negotiator dealing with constant headaches.” All those council scenes? They happened, but it was way more arguing and deal-making than royal commands.
Doing this deep dive really opened my eyes. I went in thinking kings were these warrior god-kings rolling in cash. Came out realizing they were stressed-out administrators with money troubles and too many people telling them no. Hollywood definitely picked drama over reality on this one! Makes history way more interesting though, honestly. Kinda like running a chaotic small business but if you mess up, people try to murder you.